Your SIP Money Is Losing Value Before It Even Gets Invested—Here's How to Fix It

Most investors believe they’re making smart financial decisions when they set up a monthly SIP. They automate their investments, maintain discipline, and watch their portfolio grow steadily. But here’s what they don’t realize: they’re losing money before it even gets invested.

The problem isn’t with SIPs themselves—SIPs are excellent for building long-term wealth. The issue lies with what happens to your money before it enters the market. For many investors, funds earmarked for future SIPs sit idle in savings accounts, earning a paltry 2-3% annual interest while inflation silently erodes their purchasing power at 4-6% per year.

There’s a smarter alternative that most investors overlook: Systematic Transfer Plans (STP) via Liquid Funds. This strategy can add lakhs to your portfolio over 10-15 years without requiring you to invest a single extra rupee.

The Hidden Cost of Idle Cash

Let’s start with a simple truth: money that isn’t working for you is working against you.

When you set up a traditional SIP, your process typically looks like this:

• Salary gets credited to your bank account
• Money sits in savings account earning 2.5-3% annually
• On your SIP date, funds get debited and invested in mutual funds

Sounds reasonable, right? But consider this scenario:

You’ve decided to invest ₹1 lakh over the next 20 months via monthly SIPs of ₹5,000. That means ₹95,000 sits idle after the first month, ₹90,000 after the second month, and so on. This idle cash is earning minimal returns in your savings account.

Over those 20 months, your idle money in a savings account (at 2.5%) would earn approximately ₹2,188 in interest. Not terrible, but not impressive either.

Now consider the alternative: park that ₹1 lakh in a liquid fund earning 6.5% annually, then set up an STP to automatically transfer ₹5,000 monthly to your equity fund. Your idle money would earn approximately ₹5,688—a difference of ₹3,500 on just ₹1 lakh over 20 months.

That’s 160% more earnings on money that would otherwise be sitting dormant.

Here’s how the first six months compare:

Month	Idle Balance	Savings Account Interest	Liquid Fund Interest	Extra Earnings
1	₹1,00,000	₹208	₹542	₹333
2	₹95,000	₹198	₹515	₹317
3	₹90,000	₹188	₹488	₹300
4	₹85,000	₹177	₹460	₹283
5	₹80,000	₹167	₹433	₹267
6	₹75,000	₹156	₹406	₹250

Understanding Cash Drag: The Silent Wealth Killer

Financial experts have a term for this phenomenon: cash drag.

Cash drag refers to the negative impact on portfolio performance caused by holding uninvested cash. While it may seem safe to keep money in savings accounts, you’re actually experiencing negative real returns when accounting for inflation.

Consider the current scenario in India:

• Average savings account interest: 2.5-3.5% annually
• Average inflation rate: 4-6% annually
• Real return: -1% to -3% (you’re losing purchasing power)

This means if you have ₹1 lakh sitting in a savings account today, its purchasing power after one year at 5% inflation would effectively be around ₹95,000. You haven’t “lost” money nominally, but you can buy less with it.

Many investors underestimate this cash drag effect. They focus on choosing the right equity funds, timing their entries, and optimizing their asset allocation—all while leaving thousands of rupees languishing in low-yield savings accounts.

What Exactly Is STP and How Does It Work?

A Systematic Transfer Plan (STP) is a facility that allows you to transfer a predetermined amount from one mutual fund scheme to another within the same Asset Management Company (AMC) at regular intervals.

Here’s the typical structure:

1. Source Fund: Usually a liquid fund or ultra-short-term debt fund (low risk, stable returns)
2. Target Fund: Typically an equity fund or any fund aligned with your investment goals
3. Transfer Amount: Fixed sum transferred at regular intervals (daily, weekly, or monthly)
4. Duration: The period over which transfers will occur

The STP Process Step-by-Step

Let’s say you have ₹1 lakh to invest in an equity fund:

Traditional Approach:

• Invest entire ₹1 lakh at once (lump sum), or
• Keep money in savings account, transfer ₹5,000 monthly via SIP

STP Approach:

1. Invest entire ₹1 lakh in a liquid fund within your chosen AMC
2. Set up monthly STP of ₹5,000 from liquid fund → equity fund
3. Your ₹95,000 (after first transfer) continues earning 6-7% in the liquid fund
4. Each month, ₹5,000 automatically moves to the equity fund
5. The remaining balance keeps generating returns until fully transferred

SIP vs STP: Understanding the Crucial Difference

Many investors confuse SIPs and STPs. While related, they serve different purposes and have distinct mechanics.

SIP (Systematic Investment Plan)

• Source: Bank account
• Process: Fixed amount debited from bank → invested in mutual fund
• Idle Cash: Sits in savings account earning 2.5-3%
• Best For: Regular monthly investors with salary income
• Flexibility: Can invest across different AMCs

STP (Systematic Transfer Plan)

• Source: Another mutual fund scheme (usually liquid fund)
• Process: Fixed amount transferred from one fund → another fund
• Idle Cash: Sits in liquid fund earning 6-7%
• Best For: Investors with lump sum amounts to deploy gradually
• Restriction: Both funds must be from the same AMC

Key Insight: You’re not choosing between SIP and STP—you’re optimizing your SIP by using STP to make idle money work harder.

Why Liquid Funds Are the Perfect Parking Spot

Liquid funds are debt mutual funds that invest in very short-term market instruments with maturities up to 91 days. These include:

• Treasury Bills
• Commercial Paper
• Certificates of Deposit
• Term Deposits
• Other money market instruments

Key Characteristics of Liquid Funds

High Liquidity: Money can typically be withdrawn within 1 working day. Some platforms even offer instant redemption up to ₹50,000 or 90% of investment.

Low Risk: Since they invest in short-duration, high-quality instruments, liquid funds carry minimal interest rate risk and credit risk compared to other debt funds.

Better Returns: Historically deliver 6-7% annually, significantly outperforming savings accounts.

No Lock-in: Unlike fixed deposits, there’s no penalty for early withdrawal (though exit load may apply if withdrawn within 7 days).

Tax Efficiency: While not as tax-efficient as equity funds, they offer better post-tax returns than savings accounts for many investors.

Recent Performance Data

As of 2025, liquid funds have been delivering consistent returns:

• Average annual returns: 6.5-7.4%
• One-year returns: Approximately 7%
• Yield-to-maturity: Around 5.7%

Compare this to:

• SBI Savings Account: 2.5%
• HDFC Bank Savings Account: 2.75% (for balances above ₹50 lakh)
• ICICI Bank Savings Account: 2.75%

The difference might seem small—about 4 percentage points—but compounded over years, this translates to substantial wealth creation.

The Compounding Advantage: Small Differences, Massive Results

An extra 3-4% return on idle cash doesn’t sound like much initially. But compounding transforms this modest advantage into a wealth multiplier over time.

10-Year Projection Example

Assume you invest ₹10 lakh gradually over 10 years (₹1 lakh per year, deployed monthly):

Scenario 1: Traditional SIP from Savings Account

• Idle cash earns: 2.5% annually
• Additional corpus from idle cash: ~₹13,750

Scenario 2: STP via Liquid Fund

• Idle cash earns: 6.5% annually
• Additional corpus from idle cash: ~₹35,750

Difference: ₹22,000 extra—purely from optimizing where your idle money sits.

Now scale this over 15-20 years with larger investment amounts, and you’re looking at lakhs of additional wealth.

The key principle: Make every rupee in your portfolio work before it’s invested in your primary asset.

Implementing STP: Practical Considerations

Before you rush to set up an STP, here are crucial factors to consider:

1. Same AMC Requirement

This is the most important restriction: STP can only occur between schemes within the same mutual fund house.

For example:

• ✅ Valid: ICICI Prudential Liquid Fund → ICICI Prudential Bluechip Equity Fund
• ❌ Invalid: ICICI Prudential Liquid Fund → HDFC Top 100 Equity Fund

Planning Tip: Choose an AMC that offers both quality liquid funds and strong equity funds in categories you want to invest in.

2. Exit Load Implications

Most liquid funds don’t charge exit loads after 7 days. However, verify the exit load structure:

• Liquid funds: Typically no exit load after 7 days; graded exit load within 7 days
• Equity funds: Usually 1% if redeemed within 1 year
• Debt funds: Varies by fund type and duration

Important: When money transfers from liquid fund to equity fund via STP, the liquid fund units are redeemed. If your liquid fund has an exit load period (first 7 days), plan your STP start date accordingly.

3. Tax Treatment

Each STP transfer is treated as a redemption from the source fund (liquid fund) and a fresh purchase in the target fund (equity fund).

Tax on Liquid Fund Redemption (as of 2025):

• Short-term Capital Gains: Taxed at your income tax slab rate
• Holding Period: Any holding period less than 36 months (for debt funds)

Practical Impact: In most STP scenarios, you’ll redeem liquid fund units monthly. Since you’re constantly redeeming recent purchases, gains are usually minimal. The tax impact is typically small compared to the extra returns you earn.

4. Choosing Transfer Frequency

You can set up STP with different frequencies:

• Daily: Transfers every business day (365 installments per year)
• Weekly: Transfers once a week (52 installments per year)
• Monthly: Transfers once a month (12 installments per year)

Recommendation: Monthly is most common and practical for retail investors. Daily or weekly makes sense for very large amounts (₹50+ lakhs) where you want maximum rupee cost averaging.

5. Minimum Requirements

• Minimum STP Amount: Varies by AMC; typically ₹500-₹1,000 per transfer
• Minimum Installments: SEBI mandates at least 6 STP transactions
• Minimum Investment in Source Fund: Usually ₹12,000-₹15,000

6. Flexibility Features

Flexible STP: Some AMCs offer flexible STPs where you can transfer variable amounts based on market conditions. The fixed amount is the minimum; you can transfer additional variable amounts.

Capital Appreciation STP: Transfers only the gains/returns from the source fund, keeping the principal intact.

Fixed STP: Traditional approach—transfers a fixed amount regardless of returns.

Real-World Application: Who Benefits Most from STP?

Scenario 1: The Year-End Bonus Investor

Profile: Salaried professional receives ₹5 lakh annual bonus in March

Traditional Approach:

• Lump sum investment in equity fund, or
• Keep in savings account, start ₹20,000 monthly SIP

STP Approach:

• Invest ₹5 lakh in liquid fund
• Set up 25-month STP of ₹20,000 to equity fund
• ₹4.8 lakh earns 6.5% (first month) vs 2.5% in savings
• Extra earnings over 25 months: ~₹8,500-₹10,000

Benefit: Gradual equity exposure + higher returns on idle cash + rupee cost averaging

Scenario 2: The Windfall Recipient

Profile: Receives ₹20 lakh from property sale, wants to invest in equity but worried about market timing

Traditional Approach:

• Invest entire ₹20 lakh at once (risky if market at peak), or
• Keep in FD earning 6-7% (but locked in, less flexible)

STP Approach:

• Invest ₹20 lakh in liquid fund
• Set up 24-month STP of ₹83,333 to equity fund
• Rupee cost averaging over 2 years
• Liquidity maintained (can pause/stop STP if needed)
• Similar returns to FD while deploying systematically

Benefit: Risk management + flexibility + systematic deployment

Scenario 3: The Conservative-to-Aggressive Shifter

Profile: Investor nearing retirement wants to gradually shift from debt to equity (or vice versa)

Traditional Approach:

• Redeem entire debt holding, invest in equity (tax event, market timing risk)

STP Approach:

• Set up STP from existing debt fund to equity fund
• Gradual rebalancing over 12-24 months
• Spreads out tax liability
• Reduces market timing risk

Benefit: Smooth rebalancing + tax management + risk reduction

When STP May NOT Be Suitable

Regular Salaried Class Without Lump Sum: If you depend entirely on monthly salary for SIP investments and don’t have lump sums, traditional SIP directly from bank makes more sense.

Very Short Investment Horizon: If you need money within 3-6 months, the complexity and tax implications of STP may not justify the small extra return.

Different AMC Preference: If the best liquid fund and best equity fund for your needs are in different AMCs, you can’t use STP. Manual transfers work but lose the automation benefit.

Emergency Fund: Money set aside for emergencies should remain highly liquid in savings/current accounts, not in liquid funds subject to STP.

Addressing Common Concerns and Criticisms

”This Feels Like Mis-selling—What About Emergency Access?”

Valid Concern: One criticism is that parking all surplus in liquid funds might create liquidity issues if you need emergency funds.

Reality Check: This concern has merit but is easily addressed through proper planning:

• Maintain 3-6 months of expenses in savings account as emergency fund
• Only deploy true investment surplus via liquid fund STP
• Liquid funds offer withdrawal within 1 working day—faster than breaking an FD

Best Practice: Don’t put 100% of savings into liquid funds. Maintain adequate emergency reserves in savings accounts; use liquid funds only for investment capital.

”Is the Extra 4% Really Worth the Complexity?”

The Math: On a ₹10 lakh corpus deployed over 2 years, the extra 4% on average idle balance of ₹5 lakh equals ~₹20,000 additional earnings over the period.

The Effort: Setting up STP takes about 10-15 minutes online. Once set up, it’s completely automated.

Verdict: For minimal effort, you earn significant additional returns. Absolutely worth it for most investors with lump sums.

”What If the Liquid Fund Underperforms or Loses Money?”

Reality: Liquid funds invest in ultra-safe, short-term instruments. Historical data shows:

• Negative returns are extremely rare (possible during severe credit events)
• Average returns of 6-7% have been consistent over decades
• Risk is significantly lower than equity funds

Comparison: The “risk” of liquid funds is comparable to short-term FDs but with better liquidity and potentially better returns.

”Tax on Each Transfer Seems Complicated”

Clarification: Yes, each STP installment triggers capital gains tax on the liquid fund portion. However:

• Gains are typically small (you’re redeeming recently purchased units)
• Tax is at your slab rate (for debt funds held short-term)
• The extra returns usually far exceed the small tax liability

Example: If liquid fund generates ₹500 gain per month and your tax rate is 30%, you pay ₹150 tax but still net ₹350 extra versus savings account earning ₹100.

”Savings Account Interest Up to ₹10,000 Is Tax-Free”

Important Note: Section 80TTA provides tax exemption on savings account interest up to ₹10,000 per year for individuals below 60 years (₹50,000 for senior citizens under 80TTB).

Practical Impact: For most investors, this makes minimal difference:

• To earn ₹10,000 interest at 2.5%, you’d need ₹4 lakh average balance
• Most investors don’t maintain such high balances in savings
• The extra returns from liquid funds (even after tax) exceed tax-free savings interest for larger amounts

Building Your STP Strategy: Action Steps

Ready to implement STP? Here’s your systematic plan:

Step 1: Assess Your Investment Capital

• Identify lump sum amounts: bonuses, matured FDs, insurance maturities, etc.
• Separate emergency funds (keep in savings)
• Determine investible surplus

Step 2: Choose the Right AMC

Select an AMC that offers:

• Strong liquid fund with consistent performance
• Quality equity/debt funds matching your investment goals
• Good STP platform (online facility, flexible options)

Popular Options: ICICI Prudential, HDFC, SBI, Axis, Kotak, UTI all offer robust STP facilities.

Step 3: Select Source and Target Funds

• Source: Liquid fund with no exit load post 7 days, low expense ratio
• Target: Equity/hybrid/debt fund based on your goals and risk appetite

Step 4: Determine STP Parameters

• Amount per transfer: Based on your deployment timeline
• Frequency: Monthly for most retail investors
• Duration: Minimum 6 months (SEBI requirement); typically 12-36 months

Example: ₹12 lakh lump sum → ₹50,000 monthly STP → 24 months deployment

Step 5: Execute the Setup

• Invest lump sum in liquid fund
• Set up STP online through AMC website/app or via distributor
• Verify first transfer occurs correctly
• Monitor periodically (quarterly review sufficient)

Step 6: Optimize Over Time

• Review performance of both source and target funds annually
• Adjust STP amount if your goals change
• Consider profit booking via reverse STP (equity → liquid) near goals

The Bigger Picture: Habit of Making Money Work

Beyond the immediate financial benefits, using STP via liquid funds teaches a crucial wealth-building principle: every rupee should be working for you, always.

This mindset shift has ripple effects:

• You become more conscious of idle cash in current accounts
• You optimize sweep-in facilities and liquid fund linkages
• You think strategically about cash flow timing
• You maximize compounding opportunities

Investors who internalize this principle often see their wealth accumulation accelerate simply because they eliminate cash drag across their entire financial life.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

1. Choosing Poor Quality Liquid Funds

Not all liquid funds are equal. Check:

• Consistent returns over 3-5 years
• Low expense ratio (below 0.5%)
• AUM size (larger funds have better negotiating power)
• Credit quality of underlying holdings

2. Ignoring the Same-AMC Restriction

Don’t set up STP between different AMCs—it won’t work. Choose AMC strategically upfront.

3. Setting Unrealistic STP Duration

If you set 6-month STP for ₹5 lakh (₹83,333 monthly), you’re not really getting much rupee cost averaging benefit. Optimal duration: 12-36 months for most lump sums.

4. Forgetting to Account for Market Conditions

While STP provides rupee cost averaging, don’t use it as an excuse to ignore market valuations entirely. If markets are clearly overvalued, consider extending your STP duration.

5. Not Maintaining Emergency Funds Separately

Never put your emergency corpus into STP—keep 3-6 months of expenses liquid and accessible in savings account.

Advanced Strategies: Taking STP to the Next Level

1. Reverse STP for Goal-Based Withdrawals

Near retirement or major goals, set up reverse STP (equity → debt) to systematically book profits and reduce risk.

2. Multi-Target STP

Some AMCs allow STP from one source fund to multiple target funds, helping with asset allocation automation.

3. Dynamic STP Based on Valuations

Advanced investors can manually adjust STP amounts based on market PE ratios—transferring more when markets are cheaper, less when expensive.

4. Combining SIP + STP

Use both simultaneously:

• STP for existing lump sum deployment
• Fresh SIP from monthly salary for new investments

5. Liquid Fund as Cash Management Hub

Use liquid fund as your primary cash management tool—deploy surplus immediately, withdraw when needed, automate investments via STP.

The Verdict: Is STP Via Liquid Funds Worth It?

For most investors with lump sum amounts to invest, the answer is an emphatic yes.

The Benefits Are Clear:

• 3-4% higher returns on idle cash (6-7% vs 2-3%)
• Rupee cost averaging benefit same as SIP
• Risk management through gradual deployment
• Complete automation after one-time setup
• Flexibility to pause/modify as needed

The Costs Are Minimal:

• Slight tax complexity (manageable)
• Same-AMC restriction (planning required)
• Small exit loads if liquid fund redeemed within 7 days (avoidable)

The Bottom Line: Over 10-15 years, using STP strategically for lump sum deployments can add lakhs to your portfolio without investing a single extra rupee. You’re simply making your existing money work harder.

Key Takeaways

1. Cash Drag Is Real: Money sitting idle in savings accounts loses 1-3% purchasing power annually after accounting for inflation.

2. Liquid Funds Outperform: At 6-7% returns, liquid funds beat savings accounts (2.5-3%) consistently while maintaining high liquidity.

3. STP Optimizes Deployment: Systematic Transfer Plans allow you to deploy lump sums gradually into equity while idle funds earn better returns.

4. Same AMC Only: STPs work only within the same mutual fund house—choose AMC strategically.

5. Tax-Efficient Enough: While STP triggers capital gains tax on transfers, the extra returns typically far exceed tax costs.

6. Not For Everyone: Salaried investors without lump sums may find traditional SIP from bank sufficient.

7. Significant Long-Term Impact: On a ₹10 lakh investment deployed over 2 years, STP via liquid funds can generate ₹15,000-₹20,000 extra compared to keeping money in savings account.

8. Habit Matters More Than Tactic: The deeper lesson is making every rupee work for you, always. This mindset accelerates wealth building across your financial life.

Final Thoughts

The difference between financial success and mediocrity often lies not in earning more or taking bigger risks, but in optimizing what you already have.

STP via liquid funds is a perfect example of this principle. You’re not investing extra money. You’re not taking additional risk. You’re simply ensuring that money waiting to be invested doesn’t sit idle earning negligible returns.

It’s a small change in process that creates outsized returns over time. And that’s the essence of smart money management—small optimizations compounding into significant wealth.

SIPs teach discipline. STPs teach your money to earn while it waits.

Start using STP via liquid funds and make every rupee in your portfolio work before it’s invested. Your future self will thank you for those extra lakhs you’ve accumulated through this simple optimization.

---

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks. Past performance is not indicative of future returns. Please consult with a certified financial advisor before making investment decisions. Tax laws are subject to change; consult a tax professional for personalized advice.